
Charlie Kaufman, 2008, USA
Early reports of this movie were that it polarised audiences. Some feeling that it was a groundbreaking, mesmerizing treat. Others feeling that it was self indulgent, pretentious tosh. So I had to go in with an open mind and arm myself with the knowledge that it may not be everybody’s cup of tea and that it may not follow conventional rules of movie making or story telling. Having enjoyed Kaufman’s other movies, although directed by Spike Jonze and Michel Gondry, I imagined it would be all the better for it, I hoped, I was wrong. The unfortunate reality is that this movie is indeed no more than a big celluloid wank. Self indulgence being an understatement.
Part of the problem being that it is essentially plotless. Not that this should ever be too problematic, Gomorrah never sufferd from lacking any real structure. But at over 2 hours, Syecdoche New York does become rather tedious.
Not to say that it is an entirely bad film. The first 45 minutes or so is actually pretty entertaining and funny. the creation of alternative, surreal worlds that somehow blend in naturally with our own world is a trait that Kaufman has become known for. The ever burning house, the self-writing book and ludicrous German accent are initially part of the films charm, but as the film continues, I won’t say progresses because it really does not progress, it emerges that there is actually no point to any of this.
The basic synopsis is that a middle aged man is unhappy with his career, relationship, life in general and creates a an alternative life for himself by erecting a huge, sub-subterranean theatre set and casts actors to play himself and the people around him, as a way of having some control over his life whilst simultaneously gaining career satisfaction as he is an unsuccessful playwright.
It’s a pretty clever concept, and on paper it works, but on the big screen it is just tiresome. I believe that it was meant to be non conclusive to portray that the main protagonist only had direction in his life when he was indeed, directing his life. So the play is never finished, new characters emerge and scenes are constantly written and played out but the play is never finished and never gets an audience. At one point a cast member asks the director something along the lines of “When’s this gonna be finished, it’s been 17 years”, and that’s how it feels watching this film. We get the idea of what the director is trying to say but after 90 minutes it’s hard to care any more. Had the film been trimmed to around the 90 minute mark it would have been infinitely more bearable. I imagine that this type of film improves with repeated viewing as the viewer becomes more acquainted with the surreal world that the director has created. Wes Anderson for instance does this very well, but the problem with Synecdoche New York is that the prospect of having to sit through all that again is hard to imagine, unless you bring a book or your ipod.
If you really want to see a movie about a frustrated artist, that is scared to admit his work is finished. You’re better off watching Driller Killer, at least that has some action.
AFTER THOUGHT: The title is a play on the fact that it is set in Schenectady New York and that an alternative realm exists in this same setting. This is also the theme for the Will Self novel How the Dead Live, which is also a big pile of shit.